Saturday, April 30, 2016

Final Reflection (Nace)

1)     Look through your blog for this semester. Recall various experiences with exercises you've had a long the way. 
The ones I remember most are the interviews.  They were the hardest to get.  The best part of this was really the economic model.  This is where the rubber meets the road. 

The most interesting thing by far with this was participating in the big idea competition.  It was great to actually make the finals.  There was some great feedback from the judges. 

2)     What are the three most important things that you learned in this class?
I feel the most important thing that I learned was that the market segmentation was wrong, at least in the U.S.  The consumer market just wont fly.  As I sit here in India enjoying breakfast on a “good” pollution day, I have to say that it would probably work on the consumer market here. 

3)     Which exercise(s) you found the most useful?
The most useful was the economic modeling.  That is where the rubber hit the road.  The other useful part of this was the completeness of the picture. While I really hated the pace of this course, having to get multiple assignments done every few days, the pace really allowed me to compete in the big idea contest.  I came in fourth.  I should have done better in answering the questions on the second day.  Nevertheless, having never done or seen a pitch before, fourth was pretty respectable.  Next year, I want to come back and win it!

4)     Which exercise(s) you found the least useful?

The worst part of this honestly was the the limitations of the blog.  I had to search high and low to find a way to put an audio file on there.  I had to record the interview on a tape recorder, transfer it to I-tunes, then mount it on soundcloud, get the embed code, then move it over to the blog.  What a pain.  There has to be an easier way. 

5)     What is the one recommendation you would make to the students who are going to take this course in the future?
Really get you mind around due dates.  Don’t do a half ass job of trying to make the deadline an hour before an assignment is due.  I really tried to give a lot of thought and research into my posts.  If you wait till the last minute, you are merely checking the box.  If you are going to expend effort doing the assignment, don’t waste your time just throwing something together – invest the time in your business model, otherwise its garbage and you will have to do it again when you really want to create your business model. 


This is a very useful course.

Tuesday, April 26, 2016

OPERATIONS; Expert Interview (Todd)

https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B6Fx-l3n4ngCLXNNZDNWZlJfbjQ/view?usp=sharing

Since Cryogenic Power is a company that needs to do significant research and development, I reached out to a technology expert, Ali Kashani, who has been a contractor at NASA-Ames in Silicon Valley with a focus on cryogenics for the space program and other applications.

The focus of our conversation was on the grant funding process and getting his best recommendations on where to focus our efforts and manage the process.  We easily could have spent hours on the topic because it is fairly complex, but I kept the discussion at a high level for the purposes of this call.

Managing the grant writing process, post grant management, subawards, etc are all significant operating concerns for a company doing R&D work.

Monday, April 25, 2016

FINAL REFLECTION (Todd)


Some of the most important things I've learned from this class are:
1) To directly seek out feedback from others. While this is a fairly laborious process, it certainly provided a lot of useful insights into what potential customers are thinking and how much they know about our industry.

2) Unit economics.  I don't generally include this information in business plans, but probably will going forward, as it does provide you with some valuable insights, particularly for a company that is more product focused versus one that offers services.  Building some of these calculations into my financial model is a pretty easy task that will add value.

3)  Features & Benefits.  This was a really helpful process as well, in terms of framing where we stand in comparison to the various alternatives that are essentially our competition.  This was a really powerful graphic that helped define our position relative to others and also made it easier to explain what we are doing.

Ultimately, the customer interviews were the most useful part of what we did.  Once you start to collect a significant sample size of them, you begin to get a better feel for the market and where it may be leading you.

I did feel that there were a number of exercises that weren't particularly useful and took up more time than needed, like some of the rewriting and reflection work, but that wasn't totally without value.  It made us think back on what we did and fine tune it.  I think a lot of the way this class is structured will be perceived differently depending on whether A) you already had a plan written prior to the start of the class, B) whether you wrote a plan for a real business during class, or C) whether this was merely an academic exercise for this class.   Perhaps the best situation would be for students coming into the class ready to start a business plan process for the first time with a real company.  Timing that to coincide with the start of class, however, might be a bit unlikely.

To that end, I think the recommendation I would make to students taking this class is to do just that - try to plan to start of your capital raising process with the beginning of this class.  Having a real business and a vested interest in building a top notch plan will help you get a lot out of the class.

OPERATIONS: Workflow Diagram




Cryogenic Power has a fairly straightforward process: a customer places and order, we order the parts and we schedule their install.  At that point, they pay for the work, then we do the job, test it, and deliver the product to the customer.

Soon thereafter, we start receiving customer data that we can use for our own purposes, as well as send it to the customer for their own purposes.

Longer-term, we have routine schedule maintenance that can either be done by us, or by a trained mechanic.  Lastly, and product returns or claims for damages can be dealt with as they are received.

OPERATIONS: Bottlenecks




Bottlenecks in our operations are most likely to occur during installation.  In the early stages of Cryogenic power, we are likely to have very limited garage space.  As such, we may be limited to installing our systems on one or two vehicles at a time.   Since we will start out as a fairly low volume, high margin operations, this won't likely be a major concern.  As we scale up, we will certainly need to scale up our garage space.  At the same time, however, we anticipate teaching other mechanics how to install our systems, and we will also offer sell install kits, such that there will quickly be a shift to doing the majority of installs at our HQ location to having most of them done elsewhere.

Scheduling will be an important part of our process, as will the ability for our suppliers to deliver needed parts on something approaching a Just In Time manner, such that we will not have a significant amount of capital tied up in parts inventory.  The idea will be to minimize inventory to the greatest extent possible without disrupting operations.

Seasonality should not be a huge issue, although it is possible that some of our busiest periods will be tied into the fiscal years of clients in the public sector (municipalities, schools, etc) such that they will not proceed with installs until the start of fiscal years when funds have been  budgeted for such activities.  So we need to be cognizant of this possibility.  Being based in Florida should alleviate weather seasonality, although we may see an uptick in activity during snowbird reason - coming and going, as potential customers may see fit to retrofit their RVs.

Quality control will certainly be a huge part of what we have to do.  Since safety is a consideration when dealing with a cryogenic fluid such as liquid nitrogen, we will have to ensure all of our component parts are of the highest quality, and that the parts connecting them are excellent as well.  Since we will likely have to go through certifications with groups like the EPA, DOT, CARB, etc, much of what we do will come with a stamp of approval from these organizations and our systems likely will have to be rigorously tested by some of these groups as well.

Wednesday, April 20, 2016

MARKETING: Customer Interview #7 (Todd)




https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B6Fx-l3n4ngCWjdFbnBkbVBJeXc/view?usp=sharing

For this interview, I wanted to get a slightly different consumer perspective other than a Prius owner/user, so I was able to find teh former owner of a Honda Inight.

Jody's comments about her experience were interesting.  Like others we've survey, there seem to be persistent issues in terms of HEV's not being "fun to drive".  Jody, in fact, when  her Insight we off lease, ended up going back to a standard combustion vehicle, also a Honda.

Her specific purpose was driving back and forth between PA and NJ to visit her sick father, otherwise, she didn't us the vehicle as much.

What was interesting is that Honda offers 26 month leases that allow higher annual mileage, 15,000 miles.  So there may be a correlation between HEVs and higher annual miles driven. We will have to investigate this to see if there are any statistics that back this up.

Her brother is a mechanic, and may be able to offer us more insight on how easy or difficult it is to work on HEV vehicles.  In particular, it will be interesting to know about mechanic's opinions on the electric motors and battery systems in HEVs and if the have to get specialized training to work on them.

Tuesday, April 19, 2016

MARKETING: Customer Interview #6 (Todd)

https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B6Fx-l3n4ngCVjhIbHZveTJ2ZEk/view?usp=sharing

This interview was with a Prius owner who I quickly learned was driving the car as a company vehicle.  So I had to adjust my questioning on the fly to get a better understanding of how her company was using HEV vehicles in it's fleet.

Marie Claire's company has 1000 employees spread all over the country in 38 different offices.  Most sales employees drive small pickups because they carry products.  The managers were the ones given the Prius, along with a gas card, and insurance coverage as well.  Totally paid for transportation as a perk.

She mentioned, like a previous interviewee, that part of the reason for buying HEVs in California was to get a special sticker that gives them access to the HOV travel lanes.  This cuts down on commute times, so it gives user yet another incentive to adopt HEV technology, which bodes well for us.  It might also explain why there are so many more Priuses on the road in California.

She said the company had about 20 Priuses in the fleet, and since they are also paying for fuel, it seems obvious that cutting costs is one major reason for buying the cars.  She also mentioned that they had considered all electric cars but that the recharging issue was too problematic.

She said she would be happy to introduce us to the asset manager in charge of fleet purchases.  It appears that the company has a close relationship with Enterprise Fleet Management, which raises another interesting possibility - rental vehicles.  If LN2 could be added as a central refueling point such as a rental car center, then perhaps those agencies could charge higher rates for LN2/HEV vehicles due to a much lower fuel cost to customers.


Sunday, April 17, 2016

OPERATIONS: Expert interview (Nace)



Jay is an industry expert who has done a great deal of custom parts fabrication ranging from novel fuel devices to transmissions.  He also has certification to work on high pressure devices such as boilers, steam and other systems.  He also has certifications for working on low pressure coolant systems as well in buildings and cars.  Jay worked for several dealerships and was a mechanic on the Jaguar USA team.

Jay's experience in the field tells him that this is best suited for the fleet customer who is interested in saving money for his vehicle operation.  He feels that the mechanics generally work on a flat rate rather than a piece meal situation.   In other words the standard for changing a part in the Chilton's manual says you can do it in 10 hrs, if you do it in 5 you can make twice the money.  If you do it in 20 hrs, you lose money.  We would have to have a value per car if we were paying a piece meal scenario.  For example a flat rate of $500 for each installation.

This was an easy but more complex interview.  I should have asked a few more operational questions about the size of the garage bay's needed, tools required, etc.  I guess we will know that when we actually build the unit.


REFLECTION: Marketing (Nace)

I think that the hardest thing about the marketing will be overcoming resistance to the technology since it hasn't been proven yet.  This may be aided by increasingly more stringent EPA regulations.  For example, if you buy a new F250 or F350 pickup today, you will open the gas tank and find a second fuel gauge impeded in the one you already have.  Automakers are having to think up new ways of getting better emissions ratings out of their heavier vehicles.  Now you have to make sure you diesel tank and your DEF tank are filled.  So the marketing of this might wind up being organic.

I think the hardest thing about thing about this assignment is the interviewing.  This was time consuming, getting someone who would sit down with you or talk on the phone agree to be recorded and felt nervous about the answers.  They didn't want to seem uninformed, wanted to show their concern for the environment, etc.  Essentially it was a bit nerve racking for them.  I am not sure how to make it easier but probably using the organic style that I used rather than the clipboard with questions.  I am not sure how I could have made it better.

In terms of a marketing approach, I feel that we must get the word out in publications about this new technology.  Once you have awareness its an easier sell.  We need to get trade magazines to discuss the technology.  In addition, we probably (if we have money)  need to have a pitch person that is a minor cultural Icon (Costs less money), is probably young (more to our demographic), and can show them driving a car with this technology.

Moreover, we need to get someone to buy the tech as an add on in the dealership, perhaps as an option.  We need highly trained sales people and for them to get some reward for getting the technology.   In the industrial space, we need to get a municipality to buy into this technology so we can do a grant and have the test bed to work out all of the bugs and refine the design.


Photos of new DEF fuel Gauge and tank




Friday, April 15, 2016

REFLECTION: Marketing (Todd)




Interviewing customers was certainly the hardest assignment, because it took up the most time, but it also provided us with some very valuable insights as to the nature of our business, and the perceptions of potential customers.

The biggest learning for me was speaking with a potential commercial customer in the Jacksonville Transportation Authority.  They were extremely forthcoming and helpful in terms of helping us to understand how they make buying decisions, and about how they get funding.  We may be able to partner our products with government grant funding to provide certain customers what amounts to an essentially free install for them plus the added benefit of saving money.  Who wouldn't opt for that!

I'm sure that our final result can be improved.  In our case, it's fairly difficult to come up with a super specific marketing plan for a product that has not been  fully developed.  So our marketing plans are likely to evolve in lock step with our development.

MARKETING: Budget



For a company that will start largely in R&D mode, marketing won't be a massive expense in the early stages of the business.  Because we are more likely to focus on the commercial market, we will likely focus on trade shows, internal sales efforts, specialized trade magazine, PR, and a little bit of advertising.  

Low volume business does not necessarily mean we'll have to deal with a ton of marketing expense. 



Thursday, April 14, 2016

MARKETING: Customer interview 7 (Nace)




The most interesting interview with Russell was that he is definitely a used car shopper.  He cant afford a used car.  The aftermarket purchase of CPI was possible but it really had to have an economic advantage for him to do it.  He didn’t seem to have an issue with having to have two tanks as long as the the fuel is readily available.  He is a prime example of the kind of customer that we would have in the used market. 

I thought the interview was easy, he was a little reluctant to give long answers and less detailed than the issue with Fred.  I probably should have probed more into what triggered his desire for a new car and talked about the sources of information that he used to do his research.