Monday, April 4, 2016

MARKET: Customer Interview 5 (Nace)



Connie is a transplant from California. She now lives in rural Texas and runs a ranch and oil fields. This was a very interesting interview because it really showed some skepticism in adopting new technology.  She doesn't want to be the first person out of the gate in adopting new things. Her  awareness and knowledge of hybrid technologies really became evident during her work in California.  She has a couple of friends that use the technology with good results. She was considering buying a  haybrid vehicle at her next purchase but now, with lower gas prices, it doesn't seem so important.

She does a lot of research prior to purchasing a new vehicle and gives a lot of wight to durability, reliability and particularly safety.  She wanted to know if putting the CPI technology on her new or used car would invalidate the warranty, how difficult it would be to find nitrogen and how safe it was.

Interview 4 was from a potential buyer in Houston and Connie was in a rural area in Texas where the nearest dealer is over an hour away.  It is clear from this interview that we should definitely focus on very large cities where infrastructure can be built up and there are air distillation plants nearby, thereby reducing the cost of the nitrogen.

What I learned is that each market segment is different.  Latinos interviewed in Miami seemed to be more focused on demonstrating publicly their commitment to the environment.  Hollywood and other cultural icons seem to have more influence.  Non-latino customers in Texas seem more concerned with how well the technology worked, its reliability and fill up possibilities.  They were more influenced by friends and commercials whereas the latinos were more focused on image.   Cultural differences are potentially an important aspect to do additional research when selling to the these two different markets.

Half-way through reflection (Nace)


1)    What did you learn during this month?

I learned more about my customer base and that we may have to move from focusing on consumer automobiles and refocus on industrial clients in the railroad, bus, trucking and shipping industries. We will still have to initially focus on a small test-bed to prove the technology, say on a Prius.   We can explore commercialization of the technology on automobiles and light trucks, but ultimately our best customers are going to be on larger industrial vehicles.
Some the limitations of the technology include evaporation rates from storage containers, the paucity of refueling stations and lots of consumer education. The interviews, in part, bore out other  concerns over safety, repair and reliability.  
These problems are likely less evident in industrial settings. Trains, trucks and ships carry very toxic materials such as acid, flammable gases and other hazardous materials.  Dealing with something as safe as Nitorgen should be a no-brainer.

2)    What do you like about this course?

What I like about the course is what I hate about the course.  It forces you to make progress on your business project.  My biggest gripe is that the pace is a bit much for someone who is working.  It probably should be done over two semesters. 

The videos and links are also instructional.  The assignment requirements are clear and I really like the fact that grading is done rapidly so you know where you stand.  This is a practical course that helps you design a business, adjust the strategy based on new information and reflect on the process.

3)    What don't you like about this course?

I think the pace is a bit much for people working full time and carrying and equally labor intensive second course.

4) Do you think it was a fair assumption that this course requires 8-10 hours of work per week? What has been your experience so far and why?

I think that this should be done over two semesters.  It has taken a lot more time than 8 to 10 hours per week to get the work done.  In our project, finding the research is very difficult as there is not much information out there.  Sometimes your search for an hour or so just to get a statistic or customer profile. 

4)    If it were up to you, what would you change in the course to make it better?


Again, I think the pace is a bit much, particularly for our project.  What really sucks about the blog spot is that it wont accept audio files.  I had to record the conversation, load it into Itunes, then into sound cloud, get the embed codes, then put it into the blog.  Don’t know if there are other blogs where it would be easier. 

MARKET: Customer Interview 4 (Nace)



The interview with Steve was interesting. He was a prospective buyer of a hybrid vehicle. The point of the interview was to find out if he would consider adding this technology at the point of vehicle purchase or doing it in an aftermarket installation of the technology.  Advertising was an important aspect in this Steve's decision making about a hybrid vehicle.  He did have a lot of questions about the technology that was used and was very curious about the ability to refuel and to repair the vehicle.

Clearly these are things that we need to be able to provide for any potential customers. If this technology were to be included as part of the manufacturer's build then virtually every Toyota dealer would have the training to fix anything that goes wrong with the system. If we develop it in the aftermarket mode then we need to be prepared to provide service in the city where the car is purchased. We will have to establish some warranty, in case something goes wrong or needs an adjustment. Another interesting point that he raised is the number of miles that one could go on one tank of both gasoline and nitrogen. The preferred load out would be to triple the size of the existing gas tank. For example if a Prius has a 10 gallon gasoline tank its range would be approximately 500 miles. If we added a 30 gallon nitrogen tank this would increase the mileage buy another 2.6 times or an additional 1300 miles. This makes the total distance traveled to be 1800 miles on one fill up. This means you could get better than a half of the way across the United States before you needed additional gas. One of the advantages of the hybrid is that if the nitrogen is not available, then you could continue to run the vehicle on just gasoline. You can't do that with a Tesla. After the interview Steve raised the issue of evaporation. It's true that we might lose as much as 1 to 2% of the nitrogen every day during its gradual conversion from hey liquid to a gas.

I felt okay about the interview.  In previous interviews I had a list of questions that I asked. In this interview I used a more organic, stream of consciousness approach which I think works better for me. I think I got a lot more out of the interview and was less concerned about going through a series of questions and instead could do more active listening.  I will adopt this style for future interviews. Based on the results of the interview I think we should strongly consider focusing on industrial clients such as trains, ships and other large conveyances.  I will do a couple more interviews in this retail genre but we ultimately may need to focus on the industrial sector of the market.  It this part of the market, nitrogen can be bought in bulk and evaporation rates will be much lower as it is a larger container and used as an industrial pace rather than having the car sitting in the garage for extended periods. I am always wary of using up too much time but would like to get a much longer interview to ask more questions.

Saturday, April 2, 2016

INDUSTRY: Rewrite



We were told that some of our information was overly voluminous (i.e. too many details, some of which could be moved to an appendix), so in the case of understanding the existing hybrid electric market, we created a chart that showed the basic information graphically and moved the detail to the appendix of our plan.  The make it easier for the reader and the plan more concise. 
Secondly, we tightened up some of the language in the text in order to clearly articulate the specific markets for each of our target customer groups. We may work to present this graphically as well. 
Third, we made an effort to segment the industry data from the market data so that this wasn't confusing to the reader.

We also reorganized the value chain diagram, with the explanation first, then the diagram, along with the formatted details of the chain and number of suppliers.

**********************
Below is the current revised section of our Industry analysis: 

The hybrid energy transportation industry is the primary area that Cryogenic Power Inc. will be engaged in and there are no specific NAICS codes for participants in this area. The industries that best describe what we do are found in NAICS codes 42312 Automotive parts, new and 541690 Energy consulting services.
Drivers and fleet operators are demanding greater gas mileage from their vehicles.  Communities are demanding fewer emissions from industrial sources and from vehicles.  The government has responded to these concerns through ever tightening EPA restrictions. Manufacturers are striving to achieve better miles per gallon (MPG) through gearing, aerodynamics, variable transmissions and other engineering advances, but they are reaching their limits. Vehicle manufacturers are increasingly turning to alternative energy sources.  These include: natural gas, hydrogen, propane and electric energy. The ultimate goal of CPI is help meet these customer needs and to be the alternative energy technology of choice for passenger vehicles, trucks, buses, railroads and ships.
The CPI technology that we are employing will initially require installation on a hybrid vehicle. The most prevalent of these are the gasoline and diesel hybrid passenger vehicles.  These hybrids run on electricity at low speeds and fossil fuels at higher speeds. Table 2 demonstrates the sales of hybrid passenger vehicles since 2007.  As indicated, in the U.S. there are nearly 257 million vehicles registered in the U.S. (IHS, 2015). Of that number only 4 million hybrid vehicles have been manufactured and sold from 2007 to 2015. As indicated, the market is dominated by Toyota, Honda and Ford, but dozens of other manufacturers have entered the market.
The hybrid market is in its infancy and growing. In 2012 the market was estimated $83.5 billion dollars.  The growth rate is expected to be about 3 percent a year and reach $271.9 billion by 2019.  By the end of 2019, sales of hybrid vehicles are expected to reach 64.4 million units globally (Transparency Research, 2015).   

Table 2.  Hybrid Electric Vehicle (HEV) Sales




In the U.S. there are a total of 3.1 million potential clients with hybrid electric cars, so the Company would need to focus attention on which kind of passenger would be most effective to design and market the system.  It is clear from Figure 4, that the market share is dominated by Toyota and that their best seller is the Prius.  The Prius was one of their earliest designs and has continually been refined.  From Toyota's own data, we know that they have sold over 6 million Priuses worldwide and 1.5 Million sold in the U.S. Through extrapolation of average car life, we can assume that there are 1.3 million of them on the road.  



FIGURE 4




The largest markets for hybrid vehicles is California with 698,560 Hybrid cars registered. Texas was second with 153,557 registered vehicles.  Florida was third with 150,885 vehicles.  Washington, New York, Pennsylvania, Illinois, North Carolina, Georgia, and Ohio rounded out the top 10 according to Green Car Reports publication in 2014.  
Again, extrapolating from these figures, there are approximately 30 percent of the Florida hybrid owners that have Priuses.   This creates a market share of approximately 50, 000 owners in Florida to whom we can market our product in the early stages.  


In addition to automobiles and light trucks, another potential area is buses. DOT (2014) reported that there were 872,027 buses on the road in the U.S. APSA reported that in 2014, 41.3 percent of the buses were using alternative energy and 16.9 percent of these use hybrid electric technology.  That means slightly more than 360,000 of these are running on alternative energy and a little more than 147,000 are running on hybrid electric.  These buses get an average of 7.2 MPG and travel an average of 17,500 miles annually.
Probably the most lucrative area to begin working is the railroad industry. Most of these run on a diesel electric system.  Since they use the diesel engines to create electrical power to create propulsion, the CPI technology could be easily adopted to existing systems. These vehicles last about 30 years and travel an average of 60,100 miles and gets .14 miles to the gallon (DOT, 2013). These statistics also indicate that there are 25,000 locomotives on U.S. railroads.
In terms of tractor trailers, Popular Mechanics (2012) reported that there were approximately 1.9 million vehicles on the road. Of these, a small, but increasing percentage have adopted hybrid electric technology.  Current systems which develop power from braking are also in use.  According to DOT statistics, the average mileage for tractor trailers is 5.8 miles per gallon.  The average number of miles traveled per vehicle is approximately 60,000 per year and many trucks have logged over a million miles (DOT, 2013) in their useful lifetimes.   So, based on that 1 million miles, and a diesel fuel cost of $3/gallon, a truck owner could realize more than $300,000 in diesel savings over the lifetime of the vehicle, plus additional costs savings from the lower cost of liquid nitrogen.

 Porter Five Forces Analysis 
  

Bargaining Power of Suppliers
The bargaining power of suppliers is moderate.  There are four main players in Hydrogen and Oxygen production market.  They are: Praxair Inc. 36.3% market share, Air Products and Chemicals Inc. 26.5%, The Linde Group 18.3% and Air Liquide 7.8%. Nitrogen is a waste gas in the air separation process.  Since Nitrogen makes up 78% of the air that we breathe, Nitrogen is a waste gas that is often vented off in to the atmosphere by these producers.  It is used in welding, quick freezing food and medical facilities.  LN2 is available in virtually every city.  Given the concentration in the market and opaqueness in pricing, suppliers exert some control over the price per cubic foot.
There are minimal switching costs when it comes to moving from one supplier to another.  Changing from one technology to another would be costly.   For example, changing from electric to hydrogen would mean retooling the car to run on a gas vs electrical energy.
Auto parts makers are prevalent in the market.  There are a number of suppliers and lots of choices for the components. These makers and resellers have a low level of influence over the marketplace.  This is similar in the cryogenic storage unit space. We will use a unit called a Dewar that is used to store the LN2. We will need a turbine, heat exchange equipment and other equipment that is readily available in the marketplace. All of these vendors have extensive distribution channels. Some suppliers are vertically integrated.  
Bargaining Power of Buyers
Customers have a moderate level of influence over the market.  In terms of vehicle suppliers, there are a large variety of automakers each providing many different models of trucks, SUVs, vans and sedans. Some of these automakers have entered the hybrid vehicle market and are offering one or more models.
In the train, tractor trailer, and shipping industries, there are several models that are being offered.    Buyers influence would therefore be limited and their power moderate. 
Threat of Substitutes
The threat of substitutes is moderate as the proliferation of alternative energy technologies continues to grow.  There are systems that operate on hydrogen, propane, natural gas, electricity and other energy sources. Moreover, customers can continue to use mainstream fossil fuels such as gasoline and diesel. The threat of substitutes is moderate. 
Threat of New Entrants
The threat of new entrants is limited as there no alternative energy source has been widely adopted as of yet. There are nascent competitors offering hydrogen, propane, natural gas and other alternative energy sources. It is extremely expensive for these companies to create infrastructure.  Many of these technologies leave drivers range bound, tied to their refueling center and in some cases left waiting for refueling to take place. 
In other industries, such as buses propane and natural gas are the prominent energy sources. Trains, long haul trucks and ships have not adopted alternative fuel technologies to any measurable extent.
Rivalry among Existing competitors.
There is strong rivalry among the various automakers in the hybrid sector.  Each is using engineering techniques to recapture energy and store it in a battery for later use. There has been some experimentation with respect to alternative fuels such as hydrogen, natural gas, etc. The penetration of these technologies into mainstream has been minimal. 
By far the largest penetration of these technologies has been in the area of the hybrid cars.  They are able to use gasoline or diesel and use generated electrical power to drive the engine at lower speeds.  At higher speeds or when the battery power is expended the engine spools up and provides traditional power to the vehicle. What consumers look for is reliability, payback period and extension in gas mileage.  Companies that win focus on these areas.
In the train, long haul trucking and shipping side there is minimal use of the hybrid or alternative energy technology.  

CPI will be a tier 1 supplier. In this supply chain, there are a host of suppliers both in the U.S. and internationally. These are shipped to second tier suppliers. Cryogenic Power Inc. is a tier 1 supplier.  We will take the parts from these tier 2 suppliers and then assemble them into a CPI power unit. These will be sold to vehicle manufacturers who will place them into their products.  OEMs will send finished products to their third party logistics (3PLs) companies. These in turn will be sent out to dealers who will sell them to customers.


INDUSTRY: Value Chain Diagram -- Auto Parts

n The number of domestic N auto parts suppliers is: 42
n The number of global tier N parts suppliers is: 174
n The number of Tier 1 suppliers is: 60
n The number of raw material suppliers is: 29
n The number of major OEMs is: 13
n The number of 3PLs is: 40

n The number of auto dealers is: 17,767

Market: Customer Interview #3 (Todd)

https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B6Fx-l3n4ngCUzFmQi1CM2ltVFU/view?usp=sharing

Hugh Fuller is based in Cary, North Carolina and has owned several Toyota Priuses since they were introduced more in the early to mid 2000's.  He is retirement age, so a little older than perhaps the core of Prius drivers, but the Baby Boomer generation has embraced the environmental movement and does have a concern for leaving a better environment for future generations.

Hugh's core interests with the Prius are saving fuel costs and also helping the environment.  He is willing to pay more for a vehicle in order to do his part to help the environment, which seemed to be a recurring theme in some of the previous surveys we have done to gauge consumer opinions.

This was a relative, so I was very comfortable discussing this with him, and I'm finding that I am getting better at sort of adapting the questions each customer, as they are all different and have very different perspectives, and are coming at this from slightly different backgrounds.  I tried to diversify the people I spoke to and feel like I got a good cross section - a Prius owner, a plug in hybrid owner, and a non owner.

Market: Customer Interview #2 (Todd)



https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B6Fx-l3n4ngCWFRPV1h0MGdmUVE/view?usp=sharing

Neither Steve nor his wife own a hybrid electric vehicle at this point in time, although he is considering such a purchase, more likely for his wife, since she has a much longer commute.

Steve is a very loyal Audi customer and has owned their vehicles for many, many years.  So for him, it's not really a consideration of what brand he will buy, but what model.  He said that Audi's hybrid model isn't very attractive because is it significantly more expensive than any cost savings that it could ever generate.

In considering a hybrid vehicle, the environmental impact that it makes it the most important consideration to the Bendler family.  That said, performance is also a very important factor to Steve. When he was younger, he bought a lot of "muscle cars" and although he no longer buys them, acceleration and sportiness are also important to him as a car owner.

As far as altering a vehicle, he would have no problem with that, providing that it was a "proven" technology.  He believes that a lot of the aftermarket products out there, and the claims being made about them aren't believable.

He has heard and read articles about alternative fuels, but his thinking is that it would be better for commercial and fleet vehicles because of the distribution issues.

On average, Steve keeps his vehicles for 6-7 years, and is 2-3 years away from his next purchase.

If he had a vehicle that could get 125 mpg or more, he would definitely keep it longer.

He also made an interesting point about public transportation.  In his case, he drives in the morning to a commuter lot and takes the train into downtown Boston.  He said the hassles with traffic and high cost of parking, don't make it worth the effort of driving to work, plus he can get some work done on the train or read.  So a takeaway from that part of the conversation, at least for the consumer side of the market, is to understand peoples' attitudes about public transportation and what trends are happening on that side of the market.  If people are starting to rely more on public transportation, then perhaps there will be more large vehicles on the road and less of a need for consumer vehicles.

Lastly, Steve said that if he did use a system such as ours, that he would have no problem supplying us with data on the mileage and performance of the vehicle (he tracks his with an app already) nor would he mind  having a device (a la Progressive's Snapshot) that send up the data from his vehicle.

Market: Customer Inverview 1 (Todd)





This interview was with Alfred Tom, a Chevy Volt (plug-in electric hybrid) owner, who also used to work for GM.

Not only was this interview beneficial in terms of connecting with someone who has deep industry experience, but it was also helpful in terms of understanding his perspective as a customer who is utilizing a technology that essentially competes with what we're doing.

At the end of the day, the distribution problem is still a concern, and "plugging in" creates boundaries for drivers in terms of how far they can go with their vehicles.  In the case of the Volt, Alfred said he really likes to drive on electric only, but having the small gasoline engine in reserve gives him confidence that he will never get stuck, which is a concern of electric only vehicles like the Nissan Leaf or Tesla's product line.

In the case of CPI, the same holds true, in that should the user run out of liquid nitrogen, they still have the underlying hybrid electric vehicle performance.