Friday, April 8, 2016

MARKET: Competitors




There are a number of conversion kit manufacturers and installers that operate in the natural gas and propane vehicle conversion space.  There is no central player or technology that dominates the market and new technologies are constantly improving on existing designs. The market is very fragmented with a number of players operating in this space. The primary competitors in this space are listed below (Weaver, L 2014 & 2015).  When our technology becomes commercially available, we may contact some of these businesses to determine if they want to form joint ventures to carry our conversion kits. 

When considering the competition, it is also important to think of the major substitute products.  Plug-in hybrid electric vehicles are certainly a consideration.  Vehicles such as the Chevy Volt, can get upwards of 300 miles per gallon, but have significant range limitations on electric power alone.  Additionally, plug-in hybrids are not particularly green, when the source of the electrical power from the grid is still derived primarily from fossil fuels.  Even in states like California, with copious wind and solar installations, the vast majority of power used at night (when most hybrid plugin vehicles are charging) is drawn from out of state coal-fired plants.


Hydrogen vehicles are another consideration.  Hydrogen does not occur in useful quantities in nature (unlike nitrogen), and as such, it has to be produced by using electricity to divide water into hydrogen and oxygen. Additionally, because of hydrogen’s small molecular size, it leaks – a lot.  It is also very corrosive such that tanks have to be lined at significant cost, while other parts in a hydrogen system have to be replaced frequently.  Overall, the cost of building plants to produce hydrogen, storing it, and then distributing it are massively expensive, making its overall viability highly questionable. 

Finding market share, sales, distribution, and production data on such a new and fragmented industry, is fairly difficult.  On one side, there is plenty of data about hybrid electric car sales. 


And there is also some data on some types of substitute products like compressed natural gas: 

But finding information on aftermarket conversions is far more difficult. 

One important thing to note is that a number of competitors have been  able to obtain certification from the California Air Resources Board (CARB), and the EPA that their products qualify, which is something CPI will need to pursue. 

Claims for aftermarket systems are all over the board, with a large majority of competitors claiming 100 mpg or more (although many neglect to include the cost of charging in their calculations). Our product boasts a 2.6X mileage increase, while actually lowering the overall cost of fuel needed to achieve that increase: 


Our competitive position is protected by a pending patent in the United States, and we are considering patents elsewhere.  Our primary competition in liquid nitrogen is in the UK, but they have been so focused on development (of a different type of system), that they did not patent in the U.S. until after we first filed.

Most existing businesses are very small, and lack any sort of intellectual property or significant capital backing.  They are mostly just small shops making alternative fuel alterations. 

LIST OF COMPETITORS

n A-1 Alternative Fuel Systems converts your vehicle to CNG or LNG. They are based in Fresno, Calif.
n ACME Alternate Fuel Systems. Acme Alternate Fuel Systems is based in Mankato, Minn., and offers propane conversion kits as well as training on installation.
n Agility Fuel Systems provides engines and conversion kits that are both EPA- and CARB-certified. They have products available for most GM and Ford vehicles.
n Alternative Fuel Systems of St. Louis specializes in CNG and LP vehicle conversions and compression systems. Learn more at Alternative Fuel Systems of St. Louis.
n American Alternative Fuel. American Alternative Fuel provides fuel supply infrastructure, conversion equipment, complete vehicles, service and maintenance for propane use and conversion. They are based in New York.
n BAF Technologies Inc. is a subsidiary of Clean Energy Company. Its alternative fuel vehicle upfitting capabilities include aftermarket CNG conversions of Ford-manufactured vans, cutaway shuttles, taxis, pick-ups and light-duty trucks.
n Baker Equipment is based in Richmond, Va., and converts OEM gasoline engines to run on CNG, offering sales, installation and services throughout the eastern US.
n Baytech Corporation. Baytech, a part of Landi Renzo USA, offers dedicated propane fuel-injected engines used in GM, Isuzu, and Workhorse Custom Chassis vehicles and chassis.
n Bi-Phase Technologies. Bi-Phase Technologies designs and manufactures liquid propane electronic fuel injection systems targeting fleets. Their conversion systems are EPA/CARB certified to the 2010 level, the most stringent emissions standard available.  They are owned by the Schwan Food Company and developed the technology to convert that company's fleet of more than 5,000 vehicles.
n Carburetion & Turbo Systems Inc. When this company started out, the wide majority of its work was in converting all kinds of engines to CNG and LPG. Today, most of its business involves shipping conversion kits around the world, although it still provides service for its local Minnesota customers.
n Checkeye LPG Carburetion, Inc. is based in Springdale, Penn., and offers propane conversions and complete conversion kits.
n Clean Fuel converts fleet and personal vehicles to run on CNG, specializing in EPA-certified conversions for sedans and light-duty pick-up trucks and vans. It operates conversion facilities in Texas and Oklahoma.
n CNG Interstate notes that its compressed natural gas systems are after market performance parts and do not change your vehicle’s current fuel injection system nor do they tamper with the Federal Emission Standards. CNG Interstate must equip your vehicle with your new kit.
n Energy and Water Solutions offers two types of conversion kits for gasoline engines and a low-cost kit for diesel engines.
n Environmental Vehicle Outfitters designs and installs alternative fuel systems for fleet and consumer cars, SUVs and trucks. Based in Marina del Rey, Calif.,
n FuelTek Conversion Corporation's core business is conversion of on- and off-road vehicles to CNG or LPG vehicles. Although located in the Denver metro area, they work with a network of providers in a number of states.
n Fuel Shop Inc. This Florida company provides propane conversion services, beginning with a vehicle inspection. Installation onsite takes three days.
n Green's BlueFlame Gas Company, Inc. Green's Blue Flame partners with Alliance AutoGas, a nationwide group of propane conversion companies, to provide propane conversion services. The company's Houston-based propane fleet vehicle conversion center follow quality engine conversion standards that provide the framework of an operational conversion network both in Houston and across the country.
n Hendrix Industrial Gastrux provides EPA-certified conversion kits for a number of vehicles. They do not offer do-it-yourself kits; conversions must be done at their facility.
n IMPCO Technologies is a business unit of Fuel System Solutions, Inc., and designs, manufactures and supplies alternative fuel components and systems.
n Jasper Engines. Jasper Alternative Fuels, a division of Jasper Engines & Transmissions, offers complete conversion packages, from alternative fuel engines to accessories, for conversion to propane or CNG.
n Landi Renzo USA has acquired Baytech Corporation and now offers a dedicated CNG kit for GM 6.0L and 8.1L engines, as well as the Ford 5.4L engine. The company installs, calibrates, and provides extended service for its EPA and CARB certified systems.
n NatGasCar Company has introduced a Dodge Ram 4.7L Conversion System, beginning with the 2010 model.
n NaturalDrive operates in Arizona and offers OEM-style retrofits with no under hood wiring modifications. They partner with a number of automotive facilities to offer CNG retrofits and warranty service in several states.
n Northwest Propane Gas Company.  This company has been providing propane engine conversion services for more than 60 years. They have completed more than 20,000 conversions to date, for both public and private fleets.
n Oklahoma Liquefied Gas. Oklahoma Liquefied Gas offers propane conversion services, specializing in fleet conversions.
n Omnitek Advanced Technologies offers proprietary technology for converting diesel engines to natural gas. The company says it has 5,000 systems installed worldwide.
n Productive Concepts International is based in Union City, Ind., and claims to be the only high-volume production line in the US capable of almost any alternative fuels conversion, including CNG.
n Northwest Propane Gas Company.  This company has been providing propane engine conversion services for more than 60 years. They have completed more than 20,000 conversions to date, for both public and private fleets.
n Phoenix Energy Corporation offers CNG conversion, installation and refueling equipment in Alabama and surrounding states. They are a registered contractor for the federal government.
n Precision Sales and Services, Inc. Located in Birmingham, Ala., this company provides propane conversion as well as parts and service.
n Raso Enterprises. This company sells kits, but specializes in heavy duty and commercial vehicles. There is a limited amount of information on personal car fleet vehicles, as well as off-road and agricultural equipment.
n RGR Alternative Fuels is a Nevada-based certified dealer and installer of EPA-certified bi-fuel CNG conversion systems.
n Roush Clean Tech. The company designs, engineers, manufactures, and assembles propane and other alternative fuel systems for light- and medium-duty Ford trucks and vans.
n Superior Propane. This Arizona-based company is primarily a supplier of propane, but will also work with you to convert your vehicle to run on LPG.
n Technocarb. Based in British Columbia, Technocarb designs and manufactures conversion systems that are vehicle specific, an approach the company says allows them to engineer each system to provide the best possible performance and emissions while also making for easier installation. In addition, Technocarb is a distributor of alternative fuel parts and components.
n Thigpen Energy Services, LLC provides CNG conversion services.

MARKET; Reflection (Todd)



 While I wouldn't say the customer interviews were necessarily hard per se, it was a rather time consuming process to schedule, conduct, record, process, and post interviews.  Certainly speaking one on one has great value, but conducting polls and surveys can sometimes be a much more efficient way to collect statistically significant amounts of data from potential customers.   And, with any interview, you have to be careful about trying not to lead the interviewee to give you answers they thing you want to hear, versus their true feelings and opinions on a subject. 

As far as the customers, after interviewing a number of them, you can start to get a sense and feel about overall market perceptions and how peoples' opinions are based on what they know, or what they read and hear in the media or from car manufacturers' advertising. So perhaps one of the most interesting realizations is that having a great product perhaps isn't enough.  Educating the customers on why and how your product is better, safer, and a smarter choice is really the key. 

Because CPI is such a leading-edge technology, we have learned a lot about the competitive substitutes that already exist in the marketplace.  While there aren't direct competitors using liquid nitrogen, certainly ever substitute for what we do can be considered competitive.  My personal feeling is that the plugin electric hybrid, like the Chevy Volt, is really the biggest competitor to what we do. Unless Tesla, Nissan and other all electric companies can solve the range and refueling problem, I don't see them as our biggest threat, which is sort of what I believed going into this process.

As far as the final result, I think what we have is pretty good, but I am never fully satisfied, and given the rapid evolution in the marketplace, this section will never truly be "finished", but will be something the demands to be constantly updated!

Wednesday, April 6, 2016

MARKET: Customer Segments


Interestingly, the alternative energy market for vehicles is becoming increasing more segmented.  Hybrid / Electric Vehicle (HEV) owners are generally older and less affluent then owners of electric vehicles (EV).  Electric vehicle owners are being further segmented based on their needs.  Ostensibly, the cost of an EV is directly correlated to its energy needs.  If auto makers can customize the build-out based on use, they can reduce the cost and weight of the vehicle for its owner.  As Exhibit 1 demonstrates the faster the car has to go, the farther it has to go and the fewer stops it needs, the greater power it needs.



Exhibit 2 shows how much energy is needed in terms of miles per kilowatt hour. From this chart we can see that there are different energy profiles based on the general use of the vehicle. 


From this chart we can see the amount of energy that is being utilized based on the purpose of the driving mission.     





Sales of the electric car, which will be some of our clients for the CPI technology are geographically distributed as follows:






We intend to use a similar methodology in developing our own Market segmentation plan.  The following chart demonstrates the Mission, attributes, demographics and finances of our customers.

Exhibit 5





The hybrid segment that we will be exploring for sales represents about 70 percent of the sales for CPI.  The hybrid owners tend to be female, older, making less money than their electric vehicle counterparts.  They tend to care about themselves, exercise regularly, eat health foods and are pragmatic.  They tend to be Democrats or Independents.  They are more concerned about saving money on fuel than showing off their car.  They tend to have great credit scores.  They tend to be late early adopters of technology and are moderately tech savvy. They tend to drive their hybrid daily and drive a Prius.

EV drivers will account for about 30 percent of sales.  They tend to make more, have higher incomes, are all over the map in terms of politics, tend to want to show off their vehicles and are very tech savvy.  They like the Tesla.  They are also health conscious.  The sub segment of this group are the ones that drive longer distances and therefore spend much more on the car. 

We will approach all of these segments.  The Electric Vehicle buyers tend to be very early adopters of technology and therefore will likely be more interested in adopting CPI.    






REFLECTION: Half Way Through (Todd)


Having worked with business plans for nearly 18 years, I am fairly familiar with the process of researching, synthesizing, organizing, and writing business plans.  That said, there a countless approaches and methodologies behind putting them together, and as a general rule, I tried to stay open-minded so as to continually build a best practices approach to putting them together.  Some of the exercises in the course so far have been good in developing the customer perspective, which can be immensely helpful. The concept the company may have in mind at the start of the process can change considerably over time when customer input is received. 
The course has been pretty good about systematically building on each step of the process - starting with the idea and general concept, moving through research, and then starting to synthesize that research under the lens of a customer focus.  To that end, it has been very interesting. 
I think the course was a little slow in getting started, although I realize that students are coming into the class with a variety of backgrounds and levels of experience, so my having significant business plan writing experience likely contributes to my issue. 
8-10 hours per week is probably more of a minimum level of work.  But if you're seriously writing a business plan for an actual business, it is going to require much more than that.  I routinely invest 80-100 hours of work for clients, and I've been doing this for a long time.  Someone with no experience writing a plan, could easily spend 200-300+ hours doing a reasonably decent job of it. 
If I were going to change the class, I would streamline the assignments by taking out some of the assignments that seem like "busy work", I would encourage more interaction between students in discussions (group think), and I would focus more intently on the execution of specific sections in a business plan.  Like I said, everyone sort of has their own unique twist and approach, so what I might do, may be very different from someone else.  At the end of the day, the goal is the same - to arrive at a coherent, concise, well-articulated and defensible business plan!

MARKET: Customer Interview #5 (Todd)




https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B6Fx-l3n4ngCTFBNOEk1Q3hMZUk/view?usp=sharing

This interview was with a possible commercial client, the Jacksonville Transportation Authority (JTA).   In Jacksonville, public transportation is almost entire a local bus line (they also operate a small downtown monorail system, which is sort of a running joke in town).  As such, their bus fleet is of considerable size.

I gleaned a LOT of very useful information in a short period, and given that B2B customers such as this have a completely different purchasing/implementation process, I wanted to ask a slightly different set of questions that were more probing into their buying process and existing fleet.

What I found was that they have made a fairly large commitment to Compressed Natural Gas (CNG), and that they have plans to convert 60% of their fleet to this alternative fuel technology.  They hired a consultant to help them make the determination that this was a technology that they wanted to use. Interestingly, the mileage they get is actually worse comparatively that the old diesel buses they are phasing out, but the cost of fuel is lower and more reliable (under contract), and of course CNG buses are much cleaner.

The do have 7 hybrid electric buses, which would make excellent candidates for our Company's technology.  Even better, the person I interviewed was fairly clear that they were not very satisfied with the cost effectiveness of these buses.  They were too expensive to start with, and the cost of charging and operating them is less than optimal as well.

So perhaps the big insight from this interview is the possibility that we can step in and make these buses the cleanest and best performing in their fleet!

MARKET: Customer Interview #4 (Todd)



https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B6Fx-l3n4ngCWm9SVUw4bGNxajQ/view?usp=sharing

This interview was with a Florida-based customer in Ormond Beach, Andrew Woodberry who is a potential customer who has not yet purchased a hybrid electric vehicle, but is seriously considering it.
I wanted to get some insights into his though process on making a purchase, and his awareness of existing vehicle modifications and alternative fuels.

He made an interesting point, one that has been made in other interviews, about the length of commute being a significant determining factor.  He is in sales, and in the past, he has driven significantly.  But at present, he is mostly working from home and consulting.  So a person's current living/working situation seems to have a large impact on their decision of whether to buy a HEV.

Tuesday, April 5, 2016

MARKET: Buyer Behavior Process (Nace)



This is a table exploring factors that determine buyer behavior in interviewees searching for a hybrid vehicle and also potential buyer behavior for CPI technologies.  Note that interviewees 1-3 were Latinos living in Miami and interviewees 4 & 5 are non-latinos, located in Texas.  The table also indicates the timeframe at each point in the decision making process.