Tuesday, April 12, 2016

ECONOMICS: Reflection (Todd)





This section is pretty much in my wheelhouse as someone with a finance background, and it got me to thinking about some things I might add to my own startup financial model template. 

I like the fixed and variable cost analysis along with the break even analysis, although my model imparts the same information as far as telling you exactly when you turn the corner on profitability.  This is just another way to examine the numbers. 

What's cool about contribution margin is that it really showed us how much more we're earning from dealing with commercial customers, although there are certainly a lot less of them in the market. 

I would perhaps add some graphics to the analysis that show the breakeven point over time. 

ECONOMICS: Breakeven


For Cryogenic Power, we can look at the small vehicle and commercial vehicle categories.  As stated previously, it's obvious from this work that the best margins are in the larger vehicles, which certainly makes sense given that the most significant customer value and shortest payment periods come from larger vehicles as well.

In this case, the WACM heavily skews towards the larger vehicles. Our breakeven  point is 29 units, which of course doesn't divide evenly between the two drivers, so we gave the odd unit to the side with the biggest contribution margin, as giving it to the lower margin product would not quite get us to full breakeven.


Contribution Margin
  Car Truck/Bus
Price 12,000.00 45,000.00
Variable Cost/Unit 9,400.00 21,000.00
Contribution Margin 2,600.00 24,000.00
Share in Total Sales 0.50 0.50
Weighted Avg CM 1,300.00 12,000.00
     
Total WACM 13,300.00  
Total Fixed Costs 381,014.00  
WA Breakeven 28.65 Units
Units/Yr to Breakeven 14.00 15.00

ECONOMICS: Cost Groups


Because of the level of R&D required of this technology and this company, it will be quite some time before we have a market ready product.  We are going to be fairly reliant upon grant funding as our early source of revenue until such time that we have built at least an initial working prototype, at which time we will be more likely to attract equity capital and further move towards building a market-ready product. 
Given the heavy R&D nature of our company, we will, in our early stages, adopt the accounting policies of a typical R&D-focused firm.  This goes well beyond the typical "one-time" startup costs of most typical startups. 
Startup Costs
   
Liquid Nitrogen Tank 20000
Liquid Nitrogen 2500
Prototype Parts 73500
Garage Rental 5000
Website Development 2000
Office Equipment 6000
Legal Fees 20000
Patent Fees 25000
Consultants 5000
Business Licenses 1000
  160000
Our unit of analysis is a single system installed onto a vehicle.  Our Cost of Good Sold are the parts that go into each system as well as the labor required for installation in our operations division.  After reaching a level of stabilized operations, COGS will reach about 43% of revenues.  Operating costs will normalize at around 9% of revenues, so the margins are considerable. 
Variable Costs for One Consumer Unit
Parts  $6,200
Commisions $1,200
Direct Labor $2,000
---------------------------
Total Variable Costs ($9,400)

Fixed Costs 
----------------
Rent            $12,000
Marketing     $39,000
Salaries      $254,000
Overhead     $62,934
Outsourcing  $10,080
Other            $3.000
-----------------------------
Total          $381,014


ECONOMICS: List of Costs



We have a number of advisors on our advisory board who have helped us to estimate the required budgets for our initial R&D and operations efforts based on their many years of experience in the field.  This included the PhD inventor on our management team, his co-inventor and current UF professor, a CalTech EE/Stanford MBA, and a researcher at NASA-Ames with a specialization in cryogenics. 


Cost of Goods Sold – The major component of COGS will be the component parts needed to create the supplemental systems.
Operations – The primary drivers of operational costs will be the salaries and benefits of the mechanical and technician staff as well as marketing costs.
General and administrative – This will be the cost of the CEO, COO, support staff, professional services, and general overhead for the Company
Research and Development – This will cover the CTO and engineering salaries and benefits and well as proportional overhead expenses.
Capital Expenditures - This will cover hardware, software, furniture, equipment, and ongoing developmental expenses of approximately $250,000 per year.  Depending on the level of complexity and partnership agreements, this spend could potentially increase significantly.
The Human Resources plan calls for the following headcount over the first five years of the business:

2017
2018
2019
2020
2021
General & Admin
1
2
4
6
8
Operations
2
3
4
8
16
Research & Development
3
5
7
9
11
Total Headcount
6
10
15
23
35

Friday, April 8, 2016

MARKET: Reflection (Nace)

I found the exercise interesting.  The interviews were not that difficult but they were time consuming and it took me forever to find and use a program to load audio to the site using my Mac.  The answers were at at times skeptical, but it makes the business opportunity more realistic.  Also identifying the competitors, rewriting the work, and examining the services and products was fruitful.  The tables we posted really outline some of the competitors in the industry and some potential vendors as well. 

In terms of customers, I feel that we have a lot better clarity now, in that we know that the consumer part of the market will be more difficult than the industrial side.  The industrial side offers a greater financial opportunity as larger vehicles last longer (30 years as opposed to 12 for automobiles).  Trucks and trains also go farther 60,000 miles vs 12,000 for cars.  The gas savings is a lot greater per mile.  Ostensibly, you can save enough on  a train to build three additional trains over the lifetime of the train.  You cant save that much on a vehicle.  Currently its not economically viable. 

On the positive side, the technology has a lot of promise.  Increasingly people are moving to alternative energy cars.  The most currently driven car is the Prius but the Tesla is making a run on tech leadership for the future.  This certainly could be a breakthrough technology.  As indicated in the development plan there is a lot of work that still has to be done.   If I had to do it again, I would probably focus more on resistance to the new tech, find out what their concerns with adopting it are and try to allay their fears. 


The most interesting thing I found about the competitors is that the industry is really coalescing around the hybrid and the electric vehicle.  The hybrid is the industry standard but the Tesla has the “cool” factor that people want.  They are also building out a nation wide infrastructure.  The problem with the technology is how long it takes to charge. It takes a half an hour to get half a charge.  It will only take you 100 miles on a half charge. 


MARKET: Four Levels of Product/Service


In this table, we took a look at the comparative features of our three main substitutes, plug-in conversions, liquid natural gas (LNG), and Hydrogen, since these types of vehicles are already in circulation, albeit in limited quantities.

The obvious features are fuel cost savings, additional MPG (which result in additional savings), and whether or not they cut down on pollution.  With the products themselves, we looked at whether there were additional gauges, a feedback mechanism to report data, and how safe the technologies were.  After that, we looked at issues such as refueling, repairs, warranties, and the install process.  And lastly, we looked at some of the extra features and benefits that might be available with each technology.

This was a great process to undertake because it really underscores our competitive position!

COMPANY: Rewrite



In our rewrite about the Company, we decided to make a number of changes or order to provide more clarity about our products and also to try to preempt some of the objections we have heard throughout this entire process.

1)  Design & Development - we originally wanted to start with a small scale bench model and possibly even with a working prototype on an electric bicycle.  But, as we worked through the design process, we realized that such a model would not be able to be built at a low cost, nor would the efficiency of an electric bicycle be good enough to warrant such a prototype.  As such we scrapped than plan and retooled our development process to focus on grant funding in order to have the funding needed to produce a viable prototype.

2)  Technical Detail - we were advised that having too much technical detail in our Company section would bog down readers, so we more succinctly summarized the cost of our component parts and moved the technical detail into an appendix.

3) Safety - we have heard many people question the safety of using liquid nitrogen, so we worked to provide information that would give details on this issue.  For example, most people thing that liquid nitrogen is dangerous and/or explosive.  In fact, it is not at all explosive, and could actually retard a fire in the event of an accident.  It is, however, extremely cold, so there are some dangers associated with that, and we discussed our plans to mitigate these dangers.

1.1    Design & Development Plans

Phase I: Development of an alpha prototype
This will consist of an initial working benchtop prototype for proof of concept and instrumentation.  This is to bring the technology to the next level for investors and once demonstrated, reduce development risk. 
This early prototype will measure realized performances to determine electrical output, and to measure any efficiency losses in the system.  In particular, the efficiencies of the components and system as a whole.  The components of the system are standard engineering components (“off the shelf”), however, the efficiencies of each are empirical. This work will be conducted in borrowed workspaces.
The estimated time needed for development of this alpha prototype is approximately three months (500 hours) and will cost approximately $100,000.  We may be reliant on SBIR or other types of grant funding, so commencement of this work will be somewhat dependent on how long it takes to obtain this funding.  Estimated 3-6 months to obtain funding before work can commence, unless we are able to obtain equity investment first.
Phase II: Conversion of fundamental prototype into a demo
This stage will see a beta prototype built to be integrated into a passenger vehicle, tentatively, a Toyota Prius. Using an existing Toyota Prius or similar passenger vehicle, parts will be sourced and sized in order to equip the vehicle with a supplemental liquid nitrogen electrical power system.  Work will be conducted in a leased garage facility.
Extensive vehicle testing will be conducted to provide data on fuel efficiency, mileage, range, and emissions. Estimated time to source, build, and test the beta prototype will be approximately six months (1000 hours) and estimated costs are $250,000.
Phase III: Development of a market ready product
The beta prototype will be scaled up to a larger motor vehicle such as a tractor trailer, bus, or similar large vehicle.  This prototype will be built and parts sourced with larger volumes and redundant suppliers in order to facilitate a full market entry. A larger/additional garage space will be required in addition to a production facility.  Estimated time required is six months (2000 hours) and the estimated cost is $750,000 for initial testing, certification, and first product run. Estimated total development time is thirteen months (3700 man hours), plus time required to apply for and obtain grant funding, which for SBIR Phase I & II may require an additional twelve months or more.   The 3700 man hours will be divided amongst several employees, such that total development time will likely be 12-18 months.
The parts to create the end product are readily available in the open market “off the shelf”, with only final assembly and moderate modification required at the Company facility.  For detailed descriptions on the parts, please see the technical detail in the appendix section.  Costs for the core components include:
n Heat exchanger - $400 consumer, $800 industrial
n Low pressure turbine + generator - $2,000 consumer, $4,000 industrial
n Dewar (insulated storage tank) -  $1,800 consumer (20 gallon), $3,600 (40 gallon).
n Electrical components - $2,000 consumer, $4000, industrial
So the initial total cost to Cryogenic Power for the components totals $6,200 for a passenger vehicle, and about double that for larger vehicles, such as trucks and buses.   It should be noted that these costs are based on existing U.S. suppliers, and that through redesign, further sourcing, and volume ordering, that these costs will be driven down significantly over time.

1.2    Social Impact

Cryogenic Power will be dedicated to the causes of preserving clean air, improving energy efficiency, and continuing to develop renewable energy ideas that will benefit the economy and mankind.  The Company will measure impact on the reduction of fossil fuel use, the corresponding reduction of carbon emissions, and transportation cost savings to end users (both commercial and private).  These quantifiable measures will be a part of the Company’s “Balanced Scorecord”, which will measure results both in terms of financial performance and societal good as well.

1.3    Safety of Liquid Nitrogen

Liquid Nitrogen is a cryogenic fluid, meaning it is extremely cold.  It is not, however, flammable nor is it explosive.  In fact, it can act as a fire retardant in the event of an accident.  There are several potential dangers in dealing with liquid nitrogen, as there are with every type of fuel used for propulsion.  One is the pressure created as it expands (700X) from a liquid form to a gaseous form.  So storage tanks need to have a pressure relief valve in order to ensure that the pressure inside the storage tank remains within its structural limits.  Engineering of the tank can mitigate these risks.  Second is direct physical exposure to liquid nitrogen. It can cause burns to skin after four or five seconds of exposure, but this risk can also be offset by requiring locking nozzles on the fuel tank.  Finally, asphyxiation can be a danger, if LN2 is vented into an enclosed space.  An oxygen sensor can be used to mitigate this risk.

1.4    Product / Service Mix

This product / service mix outlines the proposed offering for CPI.  Ostensibly, it being with either licensing the product by the Original Equipment Manufacturer (OEM) or buying it in as an aftermarket unit.  
For example, in the passenger car market, Toyota could license CPI’s technology and put it in a Prius.  Similarly, a retail customer could purchase it and have it installed in the CPI shop or at a licensed installer. In a Prius, this would increase the mileage 2.6 times its OEM mileage, so if it got 50 MPG, it would now get 130 MPG.  
In the bus market, the Company would likely do more aftermarket installations.  Hybrid buses, which would be range bound by refueling locations would return to a central refueling station, where they would take on more fuel and LN2.  This would obviate the need for the creation of additional refueling stations.
Most of the locomotives are diesel electric and they can easily be adopted to this new technology.  It requires the separate attachment of a rail car that has both the LN2 and also a turbine/power system. 
Ancillary services for the company would include installation of the unit by CPI mechanics, fixing the unit when it goes down, and replacing parts on an occasional basis. 

Service
Passenger Vehicle Customer 30%
Bus / Truck  Customer
50%
Train Customer
20%
Sale of Unit
Aftermarket Unit for Hybrid vehicle
Aftermarket Unit for Hybrid vehicle
Aftermarket Unit for Diesel Electric Vehicle
Installation of Unit
Adapting / customizing customer   unit to a CPI standard unit for a specific customer 
Adapting / customizing customer   unit to a CPI standard unit for a specific customer
Adapting / customizing customer   unit to a CPI standard unit for a specific customer
Warranty
Repair / replace components
Repair / replace components
Repair / replace components
Licensing
For OEM car makers
For OEM car makers
For OEM car makers

1.5    Features vs. Benefits



Feature
Benefit
1.     LN2 is environmentally friendly
Vehicle manufacturers are increasingly having to meet stricter emissions standards. For example, a train gets .14 miles per gallon. This technology saves 263,736 gallons of diesel every year for each train. This results in 5,902,418 pounds of CO2 being dumped into the atmosphere every year.    
2.     Saves money on fuel
Using the train example above the operational cost savings in fuel for each train is $243,297 per year.
3.     Quickly refueled
The vehicle can be filled almost as fast as with conventional fuel.  For example, a Tesla takes ½ hour to get a charge lasting 100 miles. Who has time for that when you are on the road??
4.     Long lasting equipment
Turbines last about 25 years, the Dewar (tank) will last at least 10 years.  A Prius battery warranty lasts 150,000 miles.  This means the ROI on the complete unit (over 30 years for ships and locomotives, will be long lasting.
5.     Off the shelf parts
Many of the parts can be purchased of the shelf making it easy to assemble, scale up or down depending on the car.  This reduces the cost of the unit.
6.     Can be incorporated into any exhaust system
This system is incorporated and utilizes the exhaust system of any kind of vehicle. This means OEMs can design it into any vehicle system.
7.     Liquid Nitrogen is not combustible
In case of vehicle collision, it will not ignite.  In fact, it can help put out a fire.  It doesn’t need hazmat cleanup, it can vent directly into the atmosphere. This increases the safety of the system.
8.     LN2 can be used for other operations
You could conceivably plug the system into your house or other application when traditional power is not available.  In refrigerated trucks, it could be a substitute for a cooling system.
9.     LN2 Dewar has same storage capacity of lithium battery
This means that it can rival the capabilities of conventional batteries.  It lasts longer, is easier to recycle and takes less energy to manufacture.  It can truly rival the battery as an alternative storage unit.
10.  LN2 is abundant. N2 makes up 78% of atmosphere.
N2 is effectively a waste gas that is created when distilling air into O2 and H2.  It is readily available in every city in the U.S. This makes it easy for customers to get.