Thursday, April 14, 2016

MARKETING: Customer interview 6 (Nace)



The most interesting thing about this interview with Fred is the DEF.  I didn’t realize that new diesel pickups ( i.e. Ford F250 or F350) required a second fluid for the truck to run.  When you run out of DEF, the vehicle doesn’t run any more or goes into limp mode.  A two liquid gas tank will even be more prevalent and acceptable then before, which may open the door for the new LN2 technology.   

Another interesting thing was that the Toyota hybrid – the Highlander costs an addition 10K for the hybrid yielding only 3 MPG better than before. Fred was interested in helping save the environment but not at the ROI that is achieved.


I thought the interview was easy and liked the flow of it.  I like stream of consciousness interviewing that way its organic.  I feel that it allows me to go where the conversation is going anyway.  I wouldn’t change the questions. 

Wednesday, April 13, 2016

ECONOMICs: Reflection (Nace)

1.   What exercises were hard or easy for you? Why?

It was tough mining the data to create the charts but in the end, it was worth finding out what things costs, what are our Fixed and variable costs and how many we have to sell in order to become profitable.   I felt this was a good exercise and helped adjust our product mix.   

2.   Did you learn anything that you didn't know before? 

I learned how different fuel mixes from a variety of vehicles can affect performance and also the environment.  I was astonished about how much money was expended in fuel for the industrial sector. The pollution was also incredible from trains and ships.  

3.   Do you like your final result or you think it can be improved.
 What would you improve when you have time.


I feel that we should have obtained more information particularly on the ship side.  We do not yet know how the bunker fuel is used in ships.  Near ports ships use diesel and outside at sea they use bunker fuel.  The amount of fuel expended by ships is simply incredible. If they run totally on diesel, we can really same these users money. 

MARKETING: Selling Cycle Description

Typically the hybrid vehicle buyers cycle is triggered by a problem with their current vehicle. There could be a major problem which exceeds the cost of the vehicle.  This could also be triggered by irritation surrounding breakdown or simply wanting to get rid of the vehicle before major repairs are required.

The next issue for the hybrid buyer is what to buy.  This requires research.  Most buyers are not affected much by ads, instead they prefer to look at research.  Within this context they tend to favor reviews and comparisons (45%), blogs and forums (30%), social networks (15%), previous brand ownership (10%).

When they go to the dealership, they test drive the vehicles that they are considering and then find out what type of financing they will get.  If the financing is no good then the consumer will go elsewhere or will continue to drive their current vehicle.

Follow up calls from employees may bring the buyer back into the buying mode. The buyer gets the deal they want and then purchases the vehicle.  They get a follow up thank you from the dealer and then have a great experience driving their new vehicle.  They will seek the perceived best dealership to repair their vehicle.  They travel 0-10 miles (7%), 10-20 miles (22%), 40 - 100 miles (31%).  The CPI product buyers decision cycle will likely follow the same cycle, particularly if it is offered by an OEM.

From the sellers perspective, he needs to generate awareness of the product.  This can be done through advertisements, articles in trade magazines, blogs etc.

Next comes information gathering -- we must put ads on facebook, get our folks to hit blogs to discuss the product, let testers check out our products, etc.

When we present our product we have customers watch videos at dealerships, see a mockup and talk to trained sales people.  They can also test drive a car with our product in it.

We then have to overcome objections.  This can be done by having a great financing package, rebates for loyalty, etc.

Finally we close the sale and create ad ons.  These may be in the form of warranties, extended warranties, etc.  We want to follow up with the customer, remind them of the need for routine maintenance, etc. We want to get the customer's view of their experience and make adjustments to our product approach.

We will primarily work with Facebook, trade magazines, and look for free publicity.  We expect that it will be distributed by 55 percent mobile advertising, 25 percent blogs, 10 percent trade shows and 10 percent magazines.  The ad budget will be 50K in year 1 through 3.  

MARKETING: Selling Cycle Diagram



Customer Buying Cycle Diagram


Selling Cycle Diagram 





MARKET: Rewrite

We added a number of section to our Market section:

1) Global Market - we added more detail on some of the international market, since we discovered that hybrid electric vehicles are far more common in other parts of the world.  This may lead us to an international expansion earlier than expected.

2) Customers - We felt that it was important to get into more detail as to why we are a better alternative than some of the existing technologies already on the market.  For instance, we detailed why hydrogen is so ridiculously more expensive to provide than our fuel, liquid nitrogen.  We also detailed some of the shortcomings of batteries.  The comparative chart we created in a previous exercise will also be going into our plan.  Good stuff!

3)  Economics of the business.  This was a critical missing element in our market section that we spent quite a bit of time on recently, and in fact, recalculated some of our previous data as is turns out that previous calculations were much too conservative.  So the economics of our technology are even better than we thought!  Very exciting!

1.1  Market Size & Condition

Liquid nitrogen augmentation of fossil fuels has no direct competitors since it is a new technology, although there are certainly a number of substitutes from which parallel comparisons can  be made, such as the liquid natural gas and propane vehicle markets (although it should be noted that these are still fossil fuels).  For instance, there are currently more than 15 million vehicles worldwide using liquid natural gas (LNG).  The highest number of vehicles are located in places that have an abundance of natural gas such as: Brazil, Argentina and Iran which each have more than a million natural gas vehicles on the road.   In the U.S. there are more than 250,000 vehicles.  Most are fleet vehicles, buses and delivery trucks. For the U.S., this represents less than 0.1% of all the vehicles on the road.  (Agee, S., 2015)
During the past five years, the growth of natural gas vehicles has been about 7% percent a year, and market penetration is low, although this growth is expected to accelerate to around 17% through 2020.  The cost savings for these gas-based technologies may be realized most in fleet vehicles where mileage is high, rather than in family cars. (Agee, 2015)
Figure 2. Natural gas vehicle proliferation in the U.S.
  

1.2    Market Structure

Most of the growth in natural gas alternative vehicles continue to occur in areas where there are refueling stations that are available.  They are generally concentrated in the middle states of the U.S.  This buildout continues to be slow.  Loves is a large retailer of gas, diesel and other services, particularly for the trucking industry.  They noted that $1.25 million to $1.75 million was needed to create a natural gas fueling area at each one of their stations.  They say that the demand is insufficient to make this sort of investment at many of their 300-stations located over a 40-state area.  They do say that the primary areas where they see growth is in metropolitan areas.  In these areas the growth is almost exclusively freight trucking where there is point to point / return to home travel and also short regional travel patterns (Agee, 2015).
In the government sector there is a desire to continuously drive down costs and reduce the hydrocarbon footprint of public vehicles.  As a result, a number of states have pushed legislation to adopt natural gas vehicles.  At the state level there was a plan developed in Oklahoma in 2011 to promote all types of energy production, training for energy workers and encourage energy efficiency.  This plan was subsequently presented at a Governor’s conference and a memorandum of understanding (MOU) was created and adopted by 28 states.  This initiative calls for governments to invest in at least 5000 vehicles a year for state fleets (State of Oklahoma, Office of Management and Enterprise Service, 2013). 
At the federal level, the American Taxpayer Relief Act created a $0.50-a-gallon tax credit for natural gas vehicles. This reduces the delta in price between natural gas and gasoline.  This makes natural gas more attractive to users. The price of the liquid nitrogen would not have this tax advantage and so it would have to compete with a price point commensurate with natural gas, which currently sells for just over $2 per gallon equivalent.  Given the much lower cost to produce liquid nitrogen, this does not present a problem.

FIGURE 3


Oklahoma also provides a 75 percent tax credit for gas stations that agree to build natural gas refueling stations.  It might be possible to get liquid nitrogen approved for similar alternative fuel credits in the future, although as a fuel source, it can be economically viable with or without such a credit.

1.3    Global Market

In terms of adopting hybrid vehicle technologies we can see that the United States lags behind a number of other countries, particularly in Europe and Asia.  Figure 2, provided by Bosch in 2015, demonstrates where most of the hybrid vehicles are located.  It should be noted that many of these vehicles run on alternative fuels such as natural gas -- which is still a fossil fuel. Hybrid technology appears to be most prevalent in Japan, with a 19% adoption rate. 

FIGURE 2. Worldwide Adoption of Alternative fuels and technologies. 

  

1.4    Customers

Since CPI’s products are aftermarket products, the obvious most likely customers are the existing and prospective buyers of hybrid electric vehicles.  Educating the consumer will be one of the main hurdles to overcome as well as ensuring that customers will have access to a ready supply of LN2. As a result, it is more likely that customers who can access a central refueling point will be more likely to use CPI technology, at least in the Company’s early stages:
n Freight trains will have large LN2 tanker cars that will be part of the actual train being run.
n Ships will have access to large tanks of LN2 at port terminals
n Long haul trucks may not make the best customers, however large vehicle fleets such as delivery companies, garbage haulers, local bus lines, municipalities, and other entities that utilize a central fueling station would make ideal customers.
n Consumer vehicles and long haul trucks could make use of either micro-generation (in garage or at service stations), or the existing network of welding and medical supply companies that already supply liquid nitrogen.
Based on these issues the first entry point for marketing this technology would be to businesses and governments that operate fleet vehicles.  They can include buses, taxis, trains, police vehicles, delivery trucks, etc.  Fleet vehicles are described as business and government owned or leased vehicles where the number of vehicles is 10 or more.  Fleet vehicles tend to have a longer lifespan that consumer passenger vehicles.  The average age is currently 11.5 years as of 2015. This is expected to increase as the quality of vehicles continues to improve. The lifespan is expected to increase to 12.2 years by 2020.  (IBISWORLD, 2015). 

While CPI can't be certain who will buy the LN2 system among the universe of consumer hybrid buyers, research shows that they are price conscious and have a number of personal traits. The figure below tells us that they have good credit, are mostly women, 25 -34 years old and like others to know they are environmentally conscious. 5. Profile of a hybrid
Figure 5



Figure 6 indicates from some 2013 information that cost is also important for a hybrid buyer.  This indicates that the purchaser is most comfortable at spending $26,000 for the vehicle or below.  This may give us some indication in determining what the price that they will pay for a CPI hybrid or add-on system.

FIGURE 6. Interest in price point of hybrid vehicles.




While this demographic information is interesting we don't want to draw conclusions about potential buyers of a CPI unit.  Instead we want to conduct potential client interviews to determine if they bear fruit.  We will focus on Florida but not restrict our interviews only to Prius buyers or to Florida as we want to get a more universal view. 

1.5    Competition

There are a number of conversion kit manufacturers and installers that operate in the natural gas and propane vehicle conversion space.  There is no central player or technology that dominates the market and new technologies are constantly improving on existing designs. The market is very fragmented with a number of players operating in this space. The primary competitors in this space are listed in the appendix section (Weaver, L 2014 & 2015).  When our technology becomes commercially available, we may contact some of these businesses to determine if they want to form joint ventures to carry our conversion kits. 
When considering the competition, it is also important to think of the major substitute products.  Plug-in hybrid electric vehicles are certainly a consideration.  Vehicles such as the Chevy Volt, can get upwards of 300 miles per gallon, but have significant range limitations on electric power alone.  Additionally, plug-in hybrids are not particularly green, when the source of the electrical power from the grid is still derived primarily from fossil fuels.  Even in states like California, with copious wind and solar installations, the vast majority of power used at night (when most hybrid plugin vehicles are charging) is drawn from out of state coal-fired plants.
Hydrogen vehicles are another consideration.  Hydrogen does not occur in useful quantities in nature (unlike nitrogen), and as such, it has to be produced by using electricity to divide water into hydrogen and oxygen. Additionally, because of hydrogen’s small molecular size, it leaks – a lot.  It is also very corrosive such that tanks have to be lined at significant cost, while other parts in a hydrogen system have to be replaced frequently.  Overall, the cost of building plants to produce hydrogen, storing it, and then distributing it are massively expensive, making its overall viability highly questionable.

2         Economics of the Business

There are a wide variety of variables that impact the economics of the Cryogenic Power system. Fuel prices, component prices, miles traveled annually, and fuel mileage all have significant impacts on the potential payback of the system in various types of vehicles. 
Fossil fuel prices have seem dramatic swings up and down in recent years as new technologies such as deep-water drilling and fracking have become more prominent, and OPEC countries expand and constrict supply in response.  Gasoline prices in the United States, in turn, have seen prices range anywhere from under $2 to more than $4 per gallon in recent years.  It should be noted, however, that prices in the United States are among the lowest in the world, and that average global prices for gasoline are significantly higher.
The component parts that will be used by CPI have prices based on what is currently available.  The Company believes that as production ramps up, that it will be able to source the same parts for a significantly lower cost in the future, dropping the cost to the Company by up to 50% within five years.  This, too, will have a dramatic impact on both Company profitability and customer value and payback period.
Lastly, the mileage of the vehicle onto which the system is being installed impacts the economics.  If a vehicle gets excellent mileage already, then it uses much lower quantities of fuel, and thus, the cost savings is reduced for that particular vehicle (although a 66-75% reduction in emissions still has tremendous value, particularly where meeting emissions standards is concerned).
The model below was created using market data current as of April 2016.  It should be noted that this is during a period of historically low fossil fuel costs.  This leads us to the conclusion that the largest customer value will be derived from larger commercial vehicles, as opposed to consumer passenger vehicles.  That being said, should fossil fuel prices rise over time, while the cost of producing the CPI system declines, then consumer vehicles will likely become much more economically viable.
The following assumptions were made in our value proposition model, based on current data:
Economic Assumptions

Footnotes Available in Appendix Section

Because the combined LN2/Fossil Fuel system can only generate 65% of the power of fossil fuel alone, we had to calculate an equivalent cost per gallon of the two fuels to generate the same amount of power. At a gasoline cost of $2.05 per gallon and an LN2 cost of $0.50 per gallon, this number came out to $1.37 per combined gallon, adjusted for power output.  So if one vehicle can travel 55 miles on one gallon of gasoline only at a cost of $2.05, the vehicle with the CPI system can travel 143 miles per total gallon of fuel at a cost of $1.37.
The follow table takes a deeper look at the economic assumptions of using the CPI system in various types of vehicles.  It calculates the cost per mile with and without the CPI system, the per-mile and annual cost savings (based on an average number of miles travelled per year), and it also calculates the breakeven mileage, and the payback period in years.  Finally, the table shows the gallons of fossil fuel saved and reduced levels of carbon emissions per year.

Footnotes Available in Appendix Section

While it’s clear that larger vehicles represent a much more significant value proposition for potential customers, it should be noted that any change on the parameters mentioned above (fossil fuel cost, miles driven, cost of the system, and mpg) could significantly alter the breakeven and payback metrics, making passenger vehicles far more compelling.  

ECONOMICS: Economic Model

Revenue Drivers
CPI essentially has three revenue drivers - consumer, commercial, and heavy commercial.  Because heavy commercial is more likely to be conducted under licensing arrangements, we expect that to simply consist of licensing revenues at this point in time, so that category will no be considered here. 
Pricing will be a function of cost, and we intend to build margins into our pricing.  As volume increase, we should be able to drive costs down significantly as we outsource part production customized to our specifications (versus off the shelf).
We can bundle our costs with installations, and also provide warranty and service programs to maintain customer loyalty. 
Margins
Margins are fairly highly.  Once our operations are stabilized, we should see gross margins of around 60%, and pretax margins of around 50%. Since we are a new technology with patent protection we will be able to dictate our pricing, to the extent that we provide customer cost savings. 
Volumes
We are a fairly low volume business, at least to start.  We will begin to let other automotive centers install our products, as well as some of our customers.  This will increase volumes significantly over time. 
We offer a high quality product that will meet a number of safety standards, and although we will be priced higher than some substitute products, we will still provide significant cost savings to our customer base. 

Cost Structure
When considering our second year expected sales of 150 units, our fixed costs will account for about 14.3% of total costs, and variable costs 85.7% of total costs. 
We have fairly low operating leverage, but we expect to lower our variable costs over time as our COGS decreases.  With high margins, low to moderate volumes, and low operating leverage, our venture offers a fairly low risk to potential investors. Offering products in three product categories also diversifies our risks, as does our ability to do JV and/or licensing deals with large vehicle operators (trains and ships). 

ECONOMICS: Breakeven Chart


Our chart shows that we cover our fixed costs after approximately 13 units sales, and that we reach break even at 29 units sales. We use an average sales price, and average variable costs for our main revenue drivers, based on 50% of sales being to commercial customers, and 50% to consumer customers.