Tuesday, March 29, 2016

Market: Customer Interview Strategy



Our focus here is to interview people in Florida who own a Toyota Prius.  We estimated that there are more then 50,000 of them in the state at present.  These will be the primary customers for our nitrogen aftermarket automotive product.

Prius owners have already demonstrated that they care about the environment, their emissions, and the mileage they achieve with their cars. Many of them are "hypermilers" who are obsessed (and very competitive) about wringing the absolute highest possible mileage our of their Priuses. Some have achieved 75 mpg by driving a certain way (so as to maximize the use of the electric motor). These type of customers, we believe, will make excellent customer candidates.

One of the primary questions we need to ask is whether or not a Prius owner would be willing to alter his/her car in order to take advantage of our technology.  It is more likely that older model Priuses will be the best candidates for this, as installing such a system could potentially void the Toyota manufacturer's warranty.  Cars out of warranty, however, are far less likely to raise such an objection.

So here are the list of questions we intend to ask:

Need Recognition

1) Did you make the purchase decision to buy a Prius alone? With a spouse s/o?

2)  As an existing Prius owner, what are the biggest challenges you face in getting the best mileage from your Prius?

3) When considering your purchase, how would you rank these factors in order of importance:  cost of the car? mileage? emissions? fuel savings?

Information Search

4) Would you consider altering your vehicle with a proven technology in order to increase your mileage?

5) Are you familiar with other Prius aftermarket services, like plug-in conversions?

Evaluation of Alternatives

6) Have you heard about alternative fuels like bio-diesel, liquid natural gas, compressed natural gas, liquid nitrogen and hydrogen?

7) If your Prius could be outfitted with a system that used an alternative fuel in conjunction with a hybrid electric gasoline engine, would you consider it?

Purchase

8) When do you expect to purchase another car?

9) How often do you purchase cars?

10) If your existing car could get 125 mpg or more would you consider keeping it, versus buying a new car?

11) If you purchased such a system for your Prius that could get 125 mpg, how important a factor would its cost be to you?

Post Evaluation

12) If you were to have our system installed in your vehicle, would you be willing to provide us with your mileage data in order to monitor the results of our system?

13) Would you be willing to provide us with a testimonial and/or appear in an advertisement?

There are likely other questions that we will add to this, including basic demographic information (age of car, consumer info, etc).


MARKET: Definition and Size

For the purposes of this post, we will define the market as a B-2-C operation.  We are going to try to sell after market units to people that already own a hybrid vehicle.  Due to our nascent operation, we want to identify where most of the hybrid vehicles are registered, what kind of vehicle is most popular and identify our potential customer base.  After this step is proven out then we will focus on using the data we collect to see if one of the large OEMs will be interested in incorporating our technology into the production of the vehicle.  While we know who the customer will likely be in terms of demographics and interests, we don't have enough data to understand who will want to add this technology to their current vehicle.  Therefore, we want to simply pitch this to those that already own the hybrid vehicle. 

For purposes of this post. we feel that a picture is worth a thousand words.  A graph or pictorial representation crunches lots of data that is not easily digestible.  Lets begin by examining the hybrid commercial market in 2016 and where the trend lines are heading.  Frost & Sullivan, a consulting firm, predicts that large commercial vehicles are the place to be in terms of production (See Figure 1 below).  Greater economic benefit is derived from these vehicles in terms of longevity, miles per year traveled and the cost of fuel as was previously discussed in our other postings. 


FIGURE 1. Hybrid commercial Market in U.S. and Europe




In terms of adopting hybrid vehicle technologies we can see that the United States lags behind a number of other countries, particularly in Europe and Asia.  Figure 2, provided by Bosch in 2015, demonstrates where most of the hybrid vehicles are located.  It should be noted that many of these vehicles run on alternative fuels such as natural gas -- which is still a fossil fuel. Hybrid technology appears to be most prevalent in Japan. 

FIGURE 2. Worldwide Adoption of Alternative fuels and technologies. 



In terms of passenger vehicles 2014 statistics, provided by the Department of Transportation, indicate that there are approximately 507,272 hybrid vehicles sold.  The average age of vehicles on the road in 2015 is 11 years.  Extrapolating from that data, we can see that there are approximately 3.1 million hybrid vehicles on the road that could use the technology.  

FIGURE 3. Sales of Hybrid Vehicles in U.S. from 2009 to 2014. 


From this number of 3.1 million potential clients for cars, we need to focus our attention on which kind of passenger would be most effective to design and market the system.  It is clear from Figure 4, that the market share is dominated by Toyota and that their best seller is the Prius.  The Prius was one of their earliest designs and has continually been refined.  From Toyota's own data, we know that they have sold over 6 million Praises world wide and 1.5 Million sold in the U.S. Through extrapolation of average car life, we can assume that there are 1.3 million of them on the road.  

FIGURE 4.  Market share of hybrid models in 2014. 



The largest markets for hybrid vehicles is California with 698,560 Hybrid cars registered. Texas was third with 153, 557 registered vehicles.  Florida was third with 150, 885 vehicles.  Washington state, New York, Pennsylvania, Illinois, North Carolina, Georgia, and Ohio rounded out the top 10 according to Green Car Reports publication in 2014.  

Again, extrapolating from these figures there are approximately 30 percent of the Florida hybrid owners that have Priuses.   This creates a market share of approximately 50, 000 owners in Florida that we can market our product to.  

The Market definition for our first foray into this hybrid market is therefore:  B to C hybrid aftermarket sales to owners of Toyota Prius vehicles in the State of Florida.  This means that the total Florida aftermarket size for hybrid vehicles is worth potentially -- 50,000 X $6000  per unit sold or $300 Million.  We will assume a 10 percent usage rate or $30 million as the value of the market. 

While we can't be certain who will buy our product among the universe of hybrid buyers, we know that they are price conscious and have a number of personal traits.

Who buys hybrid vehicles?  Well, Figure 5 tells us that they have good credit, are mostly women, 25 -34 years old and like others to know they are environmentally conscious.

FIGURE 5. Profile of a hybrid buyer



Figure 6 indicates from some 2013 information that cost is also important for a hybrid buyer.  This indicates that the purchaser is most comfortable at spending $26,000 for the vehicle or below.  This may give us some indication in determining what the price that they will pay for a CPI hybrid.


FIGURE 6. Interest in price point of hybrid vehicles.




While this demographic information is interesting we don't want to draw conclusions about potential buyers of a CPI unit.  Instead we want to conduct potential client interviews to determine if they bear fruit.  We will focus on Florida but not restrict our interviews only to Prius buyers or to Florida as we want to get a more universal view.




Saturday, March 26, 2016

SUMMARY: Rewrite

For this exercise most of the comments received were not on the description of the problem but further clarifying the solution.  The areas of the rewrite are to further clarify and underscore the kind of vehicle that this technology can be utilized for, how it might be used in the future and what the technological hurdles might be. 

Problem: Countries all over the world are struggling to reduce emissions and have enacted increasingly stringent regulations, particularly with respect to vehicles, trains and ships.  Customers are also demanding higher miles per gallon (MPG) ratings from their vehicles and are using this as a criterion in the selection of their next vehicle purchase. Manufacturers are trying to stay ahead of these regulations and are increasingly extending their MPG ratings through aerodynamics, gearing, weight reduction, braking, etc.  While these improvements have been substantial, manufacturers are increasingly turning to alternative energy systems for future improvements in emissions reduction.

The solution: Our proprietary Cryogenic Power generation system uses nitrogen to extend the gas mileage in any hybrid vehicle by 2.6 times its current mileage.  The technology only currently works on hybrid technology because it uses the battery pack to store energy and use it later to move the vehicle.  It uses exhaust from a standard combustion engine to heat the liquid nitrogen (LN2) from its 196 degrees Celsius, (or -321 degrees Fahrenheit) and turn it rapidly into a gas. That conversion from a liquid to a gas puts out 41,000 pounds per square inch of force.  In order to get a similar PSI, you would have to go over twice as deep as the Marianas trench (the deepest point in earths oceans). 

This force is easily demonstrated by student who put a small amount of LN2 into a 2 liter coke bottle and screwed on the lid.  With no escape value, you see the impact of the LN2 expanding from its liquid state into a gas 700 times its volume.  The video link is available here. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o3eP_ZNYi_U 

Imagine that same force being safely sent into a turbine that then creates electricity that can be sent back into the battery.  The technology could eventually be used to power a conventional car, through direct mechanical power or even replacing the existing combustion engine.  This would require solving the problem of having a low energy heat source that can quickly transfer the liquid into a gas.  As you can see from the referenced video, it took almost 12 minutes to do that using a warm liquid.  This timeframe is not acceptable for the purposes of driving electricity.  It has to be more immediate than that and that is why we use the vehicle's exhaust to accelerate the process. 

The hurdles that exist for use of this technology by an ordinary driver are that it could create frostbite given the extreme storage temperature. Safety precautions would have to be taken (i.e. wearing gloves and shop glasses).  This would have to be engineered out of the fill up procedure so that the driver had something like a gas pump to use for a fill up.   

Similarly, If the safety valves were either plugged up or deliberately blocked, there would either be an explosion, like you see in the video. In order to avoid that the Dewar (storage tank) would have to be engineered to fail or open, releasing the nitrogen gas harmlessly into the atmosphere.


Our primary customer is the transportation industry. Our eventual goal is to get the system into all types of vehicles. Given the recent drop in fossil fuel prices, we will focus on heavy vehicles first, where the fuel savings and emission reduction will be felt most: buses, trucks, trains and ships. Given the brevity of this submission, let’s focus on potential benefits for the railroad market.  Locomotives use diesel engines to produce electricity, which powers a train.  According to the 2013 Bureau of Transportation Statistics, there were over 25,000 locomotives in operation in the U.S. They also reported that a train gets an average of .14 MPG and travels an average of 60,000 miles a year. Despite the cost of diesel fuel plunging to a recent low of $1.86 per gallon, using the Cryogenic Power system could further drop the cost of fuel from $13.29 a mile to $9.23 per mile -- resulting in a savings of $243,000 per year or $7.3 million over the locomotive’s 30-year lifespan.  Moreover, this would save 263,736 gallons of diesel fuel annually.  The EPA estimates each gallon of diesel fuel expended results in 22.38 pounds of CO2 emissions, along with other harmful gases. Installation of the Cryogenic Power system would therefore prevent 5,902,418 pounds of CO2 from entering the atmosphere every year.  If diesel prices return to $4 pre-collapse levels, the cost savings could easily be double that of the projected amount.  It could be even more if we drive the price of liquid nitrogen (LN2) below $.50 a gallon, which we believe could be achieved when purchased in bulk quantities.



Beyond the vehicle market, this system could be used to store energy created by solar, wind or other alternative energy generation sources in remote areas, where traditional fuel delivery is sporadic or costly.  The CPI system has roughly the same energy storage equivalent of a lithium battery. Unlike chemicals found in batteries, LN2 is inert.  A LN2 storage container can generally last at least 10 years and is easily recycled, as opposed to a battery cell.

COMPANY: Reflection

The company reflection

The company section of the case was tough in that it required a lot of introspective reflection on what it will take to do make the company work.  The product mix was an interesting exercise in that you really had to determine how much of your sales were going to derived from what product.  Then you started to consider some of the extension products.  For example, its not enough just to sell the unit to people, you have to service it.  Do you wait for them to call with a problem or do you plan for it and offer a warranty?  This warranty service not only gives the client piece of mind that you stand behind the product but also allows you to keep mechanics employed based on the fees collected from the warranty on the product. 

In a similar vein, we can’t expect for the client to try to figure out how to get nitrogen in his local city.  We need to set up agreements with local air purifying companies in order to provide it to our consumers.  For this logistical service we can make a small profit on these deliveries.  We are buying in bulk so we can organize delivery schedules, etc. for our clients.

Some of our clients will invariably like to design their own systems and incorporate it into the manufacture of their own products.  This is fine as we can sub-license this technology to others.  This may include bus manufacturers, train makers, even heavy truck manufacturers.  The product mix was an interesting exercise and really made you think about the logistical aspects of the company.

I particularly liked the dream section.  It helped me put into perspective what kind of company I wanted to be and why I was in business.  Most of it was capital growth, but another part was socially oriented, wanting to do what I could about the growing amount of pollution based on the use of fossil fuels.  I see in Alaska where trees are growing where they used not to, where ice sheets are rapidly melting and weather around the world is going haywire.  Rising water temperatures are killing off the great barrier reef in Australia and causing other problems worldwide. 


I feel the competitive advantage section was also interesting.  It made you focus on the barriers to entry that you need to throw up to keep other companies at bay.  In this case, we have IPR protection in the form of a patent. Ultimately, I think the patent will be the gateway patent for other firms that want to do business in this space.  I also think that the company needs to develop the capability, like drug companies – specialize in one part of the process.  Through specialization,  we can develop expertise and economies of scale.  In big pharma, there are firms that specialize in research.  Other firms specialize in distribution and sales.   

All in all a very interesting exercise. I am not really sure there is much more I can do in this regard, other than see what other products I could add outside this technology but in the same space such as solar or wind related products